We reviewed 11 XDR solutions (extended detection and response) and installed five of them on Windows Server 2022, four of them also on Ubuntu 24.04. We ran attack simulations on all five, file-encryption tests on two, and checked 29 criteria and 22 sub-metrics.
All five offer every feature on our 23-item, such as host isolation and SIEM export. They differed in Windows agent memory (138 MB to 1,174 MB), on-premises console options, alert retention, license terms and default settings.
Top 11 XDR solutions
XDR benchmark summary
The table lists only the results that differ.
- Deployment channels: manual, CLI/script, GPO, MDM/Intune, SCCM/MECM, configuration management, console push.
- Dashboard options: add, remove and move widgets, filter by time or host, save a personal view, reopen it. IoC types: hash, IP, domain, URL.
- Windows installer time runs from launch to the completion message and leaves out registration, later component installs and, for Trend Micro, the separate sensor package.
- Windows agent RAM is one snapshot per vendor under its own policy and workload. Retention covers a different record type at each vendor.
Of the five tested vendors, only Trend Micro documents full XDR with no internet connection, through a separately licensed Sovereign Private Cloud. Acronis and Bitdefender offer on-premises consoles, but their XDR analytics run in the cloud.
- All five platforms ship Windows and Linux agents and support behavioral threat detection, MITRE ATT&CK mapping, host isolation, encrypted-file recovery, automated response playbooks, threat hunting, offline endpoint protection, and alert views with process tree, command line, host and timestamp.
- All five also take in email and identity data, and offer SIEM export, an API, import of custom indicators of compromise (IoCs), IT service management (ITSM) ticketing, threat intelligence feeds with alert enrichment, and scheduled reports.
Agent resource usage
| Name | Memory (MB) |
|---|---|
| CrowdStrike | 138 |
| Acronis | 432 |
| Trend Micro | 593 |
| Sophos | 661 |
| Bitdefender | 1174 |
Each value is one snapshot of agent process memory on Windows Server 2022, taken during that vendor’s own test round, so policies and workloads differed. The table shows what each Windows value includes, plus the Linux results:
Installation time
| Name | Installer time (seconds) |
|---|---|
| Acronis | 50 |
| CrowdStrike | 65 |
| Bitdefender | 250 |
| Sophos | 263 |
| Trend Micro | 300 |
The bars show the time from launching the Windows installer to its completion message. We used each vendor’s manual installer.
- CrowdStrike and Bitdefender finished without a reboot, and Sophos continued past a recommended restart. Trend Micro’s Apex One installer required one.
- Acronis and Sophos download components during installation. Acronis’s installer finished in about 50 seconds, but after registration the console’s activity log shows agent components installing for about four more minutes.
- Trend Micro’s first package registered the server as “Sensor only,” and the sensor showed “Running” 25 minutes after install. Anti-malware needed a second, 890 MB Apex One package.
- On Ubuntu 24.04, CrowdStrike installed in 7 seconds once the package was copied, Bitdefender in 52 seconds and Sophos in 53 seconds.
Agent deployment channels
All five document manual installation, CLI/script installation and MDM/Intune. Trend Micro’s documented script does not cover its Standard Endpoint Protection agent. The other four channels split as follows:
Threat detection and blocking
All five platforms document behavioral detection with blocking. Every console tagged alerts with ATT&CK technique IDs, the labels MITRE’s public ATT&CK catalog gives to attacker techniques. Blocking and automatic remediation depended on settings that several products ship switched off:
- CrowdStrike‘s default policy logged the EICAR antivirus test file as an Informational detection without blocking it. Blocking started after we assigned a stricter prevention policy (machine learning set to detection Aggressive, prevention Moderate).
- Incidents from Acronis’s main test set stayed “Not mitigated.” Its EDR playbooks are off by default; after we enabled them, new incidents closed as “Auto mitigated.”
- Trend Micro‘s Behavior Monitoring is off by default on Windows Server, and its “Assess” action logs activity without blocking it.
What each product blocked or quarantined in our Windows tests:
- Acronis: Active Protection mitigated the RanSim run and restored the 17 encrypted files; antivirus scanning quarantined nbtscan and an EICAR test file.
- CrowdStrike: Under the stricter policy: rundll32 and certutil attempts (“Access is denied”); mimikatz and AMSI-bypass scripts, which try to switch off Windows script scanning; 12 files dropped by APTSimulator
- Bitdefender: PowerShell launched through Windows Management Instrumentation (WMI); an EICAR file written over SMB
- Trend Micro: An EICAR file, gone from disk 3 seconds after it was written; mimikatz.exe, quarantined after it was copied, and a later attempt to run it failed with “Access is denied”
- Sophos: A comsvcs.dll LSASS memory dump (a credential-theft technique) and an AMSI bypass (AMSI/Bypass-J); mimikatz was flagged as a High-priority threat graph
MITRE ATT&CK mapping
Every console tagged alerts with ATT&CK technique IDs, the labels MITRE’s public ATT&CK catalog gives to attacker techniques:
- Acronis: Technique IDs listed on the incident (for example T1047 and T1059.001), with STIX export
- CrowdStrike: Tactic and technique on each detection, such as Credential Access via OS Credential Dumping
- Bitdefender: Techniques listed per incident, with each alert’s tactic in the Events tab
- Trend Micro: Mimikatz event tagged T1003, T1204.002 and ATT&CK software ID S0002
- Sophos: Technique IDs in threat graph names, such as Creds_4b (T1003.001) and Lateral_1b (T1105)
Alert correlation
All five document grouping related security events into incidents. Our attack tests ran on endpoints, so the list shows how each console presented endpoint alerts:
- Acronis: The AI attack summary merged remote execution through WMI and logon persistence into one attack chain
- CrowdStrike: One detection panel combined process tree, event timeline, hash details and threat intelligence
- Bitdefender: Related alerts and artifacts collected in one incident, with a process graph
- Trend Micro: New alerts joined the same Workbench insight over three days, and its score rose as they did
- Sophos: Threat graphs and cases created automatically; Sophos AI merged two mimikatz detections into one case summary
Incident response automation
Acronis was the only product whose playbooks we ran. Once enabled, they closed new incidents as “Auto mitigated.” For the other four, our records cover the playbook builders and documentation.
Ransomware recovery
All five document a way to recover files that ransomware encrypted. The mechanisms differ:
We ran live file-encryption tests on Acronis and Bitdefender only. For CrowdStrike, Trend Micro and Sophos, the recovery table above reflects documentation. Each product appears twice because each was tested under two setups:
- Only the RanSim run on Acronis restored files. The two Acronis setups differ in two ways, the EDR pack and the test tool, so the result does not isolate the pack’s effect.
- Bitdefender quarantined the script as CMD:Heur.BZC.PZQ.Boxter on write, before encryption began. After a scan exclusion was added, the script encrypted 20 and then 200 files; none was restored, and the Ransomware Activity report stayed empty.
- Two of the five documented mechanisms need a person to act: CrowdStrike’s RTR script and Trend Micro’s approval prompt.
Threat hunting and data retention
Each vendor’s documented retention covers a different record type:
Each vendor has its own query tool: Acronis XQL, CrowdStrike Next-Gen SIEM Event Search, Bitdefender Historical Search with endpoint IOC scans, Trend Micro Search and XDR Data Explorer, and Sophos Live Discover with SQL-like queries. A “mimikatz” search in CrowdStrike returned 18 events for one day.
Integration with existing security tools
All five forward security incidents to a SIEM and open tickets in IT service management tools. The paths differ:
All five import custom hash and IP indicators. Domain and URL support varies:
For Acronis, Bitdefender and Sophos, part of this coverage comes through the Lumu integration, which requires its own license. Trend Micro’s console also listed TAXII and MISP threat-sharing feeds as third-party intelligence sources.
Threat intelligence integration
All five vendors publish research on Lazarus campaigns linked to North Korea. In CrowdStrike, a vulnerable-driver detection on our server showed ETHEREAL PANDA under “Related adversaries,” a state-backed group with 10 intelligence reports.
Reporting and compliance
All five keep a history of response actions, which audits can draw on: Acronis Incident Activities, CrowdStrike Real Time Response audit logs, Bitdefender’s Response view, Trend Micro Response Management and Sophos Live Response session audits.
Earlier attack simulation results
Our first hands-on round ran Windows attack simulations covering signature detection, living-off-the-land binaries, lateral movement and persistence. Test counts and policies differed by vendor, so read each row on its own rather than as a ranking.
- CrowdStrike detected registry Run keys, scheduled tasks and event-log clearing but did not block them, even under the stricter policy.
- Sophos detected encoded PowerShell, rundll32 and event-log clearing without blocking them, and missed Defender disabling and registry and scheduled-task persistence.
- Trend Micro missed encoded PowerShell, a certutil download, an AMSI bypass, event-log clearing, Defender disabling, and registry Run key and scheduled-task persistence.
- Attempts to stop the agent’s own service were rejected on CrowdStrike, Sophos and Trend Micro.
1. Acronis Cyber Platform
Acronis Cyber Platfrom runs backup, anti-malware and EDR from one agent. Its console holds backup storage, protection plans, EDR playbooks, SIEM forwarding plans and incidents.
Linux protection depends on kernel compatibility. Acronis documents Ubuntu 24.04 for EDR and anti-malware, but on our Ubuntu 24.04 server (kernel 6.8) the console marked both modules “Not applicable,” and on AlmaLinux 9.8 the kernel module did not compile. On CentOS 7.9 (kernel 3.10), the agent quarantined an EICAR file.
Advanced Email Security runs in a separate console built on Perception Point. Once connected, email and identity events appear in the same incident view, and responses include suspending a user and blocking an Entra ID account.
Incidents show a kill-chain process tree, an AI attack summary and a button that sends the incident to Microsoft Security Copilot. After isolation, analysts can open a command line, transfer files or take a screenshot; screenshots require two-factor authentication.
A CyberFit Score widget rated our server 450 of 850, split across anti-malware, backup, firewall, VPN, disk encryption and NTLM. The script repository held 109 scripts plus an AI script generator.
Deployment options include offline installers for 32-bit, 64-bit and ARM, remote install through device discovery, and registration tokens that attach a protection plan. Installers cover workstations, servers, virtual machines and mobile devices.
XDR depends on Acronis’s cloud EDR service. Cyber Protect Local and Cyber Protect for OT keep management on site but provide local protection only.
2. CrowdStrike Falcon Insight XDR
Falcon is cloud-only. The customer picks a region (EU-1, US-1, US-2 or GovCloud) and runs endpoint, identity, SIEM and SOAR (security orchestration, automation and response) modules from one web console.
- The Linux sensor runs on eBPF, so Ubuntu 24.04 needed no kernel module build. It does need Falcon sensor 7.19.17219 or later.
- Host management listed the Windows and Ubuntu servers in one table, under the same host group and policy.
- Detections were labeled with CrowdStrike categories such as AI Powered IOA and Machine Learning via Cloud-based ML. One blocked mimikatz detection carried global and local prevalence, 43 contextual behaviors, a SHA256 hash panel and a Google Threat Intelligence tab.
- IOC management accepts CSV or JSON uploads, and each indicator takes a platform, host group, severity, expiry date and audit note.
- Network contain isolates a host while keeping the Real Time Response session open for investigation. The prevention policy can stop ransomware from deleting shadow copies, which RTR-based file recovery relies on.
3. Sophos Intercept X
Sophos Central is SaaS only. The older Sophos Enterprise Console is a separate product without Central’s XDR features.
- The Windows installer was a 2.66 MB stub that warned it would remove third-party security software. It finished in 4 minutes 23 seconds, against an on-screen estimate of 10 minutes.
- My Products listed Endpoint, Server, Email Security, NDR, Identity, ZTNA and Firewall Management, and the Threat Analysis Center holds Cases, Detections, AI Search, Threat Graphs and Live Discover.
- The endpoint logged 9 malicious-behavior and 3 malware or PUA detections. The console counted 42 detections for the server in 24 hours, and its MITRE chart showed Defense Evasion 17, Credential Access 13 and Execution 12.
- Sophos AI summarized a mimikatz case across six ATT&CK stages and suggested three follow-up queries. Attempts to stop five Sophos services returned error code 5, and the services kept running.
- On Ubuntu, the agent ran in XDR Sensor mode, which includes no antivirus, and tamper protection showed as “Not applicable.” It still flagged a reverse shell and an ingress tool transfer at Medium severity.
- Behavior analysis, CryptoGuard and exploit protection run on the device; without internet, telemetry is stored locally and sent to Central when the connection returns.
4. Bitdefender GravityZone
GravityZone runs as a cloud console (version 6.73 in our test) or on premises, with XDR features in the cloud version.
- The Install Protection wizard offers four methods: local install, an email link to the user, a relay package and push from the console through a relay.
- The console listed Office 365, Active Directory, Azure AD, Intune, Google Workspace, Atlassian Cloud and Okta connectors.
- Incidents, Response, Threats Xplorer and Network pages carried 34 preset views in total, each list with a Custom section for saved views.
- The endpoint details page listed Advanced Threat Control as On, and HyperDetect sensitivity can be set to Permissive, Normal or Aggressive. Custom rules’ automatic actions are tracked as Action needed, In progress, Completed or Dismissed.
- The primary scan engine was Central Scan, with Hybrid Scan as backup; Local Scan (Full Engines) keeps engines and security content on the device for offline use.
- The incident list has an Actors column, which stayed empty for our incidents; actor profiles come with the IntelliZone add-on.
5. Trend Micro Vision One
Vision One is a SaaS platform with 10 security modules in one menu, including identity, email, network, cloud and mobile security. On-premises Apex Central and Deep Security Manager deployments can connect to it.
- Protection takes two agents. The first package registered the server as “Sensor only” and warned “Protection features not installed”; the 890 MB Apex One package took about five minutes to install and required a reboot.
- In the first test run, mshta and rundll32 attempts did not open calc.exe, yet the console showed no matching alert. In a later re-run, both processes started.
- One Workbench insight showed only the Execution stage on day one; by day three it covered seven ATT&CK tactics, including Credential Access and Privilege Escalation. The same insight listed “Security Playbooks: None,” with a link to run one manually.
- Without a connection to its server, Apex One’s real-time scan keeps running on local signatures, and Vision One correlation resumes once the connection returns.
- Attack Surface Discovery gave our server a risk score of 72 and flagged two high-risk CVEs (CVE-2024-9680, CVE-2025-33053). The Companion assistant answered our questions in Turkish.
6. Stellar Cyber Open XDR
Stellar Cyber’s Open XDR platform takes in data from the security tools an organization already runs, through more than 400 prebuilt integrations, according to the vendor.1 Stellar Cyber positions it to run on top of existing EDR, firewall and identity tools instead of replacing them.

Source: Stellar Cyber
Key features:
- Machine learning correlation: data from any source is normalized and enriched with context, and correlated incidents include the underlying data
- Next-gen SIEM, a threat intelligence platform (TIP), UEBA, file integrity monitoring, IDS, NDR and SOAR in one platform
7. SentinelOne Singularity XDR
SentinelOne’s Singularity platform extends endpoint detection and response with its own AI-SIEM. Its Purple AI assistant works on data from SentinelOne and third-party sources.2
Key features:
- Purple AI answers analysts’ questions without a written query, produces AI-generated summaries and runs agentic investigations that suggest next steps
- 1-click Rollback restores files and configurations changed by an attacker; according to SentinelOne, most rollback features work on Windows and use Windows Volume Shadow Copy, which the agent protects from tampering3
- The Storyline view organizes endpoint events into a single narrative for investigation
8. Cisco XDR
Cisco XDR replaced Cisco SecureX, whose support ended on July 31, 2024. SecureX customers do not inherit Cisco XDR; it is a separate paid subscription.4 The platform brings Cisco and third-party security solutions together.5
Key features:
- Took over SecureX orchestration, dashboards, threat response, integrations and device insights
- Enriches incident data with Cisco Talos threat intelligence and asset context
9. Exabeam New-Scale Security Operations Platform
Exabeam sells New-Scale Fusion as its New-Scale Security Operations Platform, combining SIEM, user and entity behavior analytics (UEBA) and automation.6
Key features:
- Agent Behavior Analytics (ABA), added in the January 2026 New-Scale launch, extends behavioral monitoring to AI agents7
- Ingests activity from AI tools such as ChatGPT, Gemini and Microsoft Copilot
- Outcomes Navigator maps detection coverage to security frameworks
10. Microsoft Defender XDR
Microsoft Defender XDR correlates alerts and events from Microsoft security products, including Defender for Endpoint, Defender for Office 365, Defender for Identity and Defender for Cloud Apps, into incidents in the Microsoft Defender portal.8
Key features:
- Incidents bring email, identity and endpoint alerts for one attack into a single attack story
- Automated investigation and response, and attack disruption, act on alerts and incidents automatically
- Microsoft Sentinel runs in the same portal; after March 31, 2027, Sentinel will no longer be supported in the Azure portal
- Security Copilot is built into the Defender portal
11. Palo Alto Cortex XDR
Palo Alto Networks says Cortex XDR connects data from endpoint, network, cloud, identity and email sources.9
Key features:
- Palo Alto reports 100% technique-level detection with no delays or configuration changes in the 2024 MITRE ATT&CK Enterprise evaluation, and 8 of 10 attack steps prevented with zero false positives10
- Visibility into network traffic, user behavior and endpoint activity, according to the vendor
How to evaluate XDR solutions
- Pilot on your own OS and kernel mix. Acronis documents Ubuntu 24.04 support, but our server ran backup only; CrowdStrike needs sensor 7.19.17219 or later on Ubuntu 24.04; our Trend Micro trial had no Linux license.
- Check which license each feature needs. Acronis’s EDR features need its EDR pack, CrowdStrike’s blocking needs Falcon Prevent, Bitdefender’s automatic actions need a protection license, Sophos’s XDR sensor mode includes no antivirus, and Trend Micro’s offline XDR is a separate product.
- Roll out in phases, starting in detection mode and reviewing alerts against your own admin scripts before enabling prevention and playbooks. Acronis’s playbooks and Trend Micro’s Behavior Monitoring on Windows Server are off by default, and CrowdStrike’s default policy did not block EICAR.
- For compliance, check what each retention period covers. Incident and alert retention was 90 to 180 days at four vendors, CrowdStrike documents up to 365 days for Threat Graph detections, and Sophos deletes resolved self-managed cases after 30 days.
- Plan endpoint memory for the agent. Windows snapshots ranged from 138 MB to 1,174 MB.
- Map integrations to your existing security infrastructure: SIEM connector, ITSM tool and API rate limits.
XDR vs EDR vs SIEM
CrowdStrike (Next-Gen SIEM) and Trend Micro (Agentic SIEM and XDR) include log search in the same console as XDR. Teams that run EDR, email security and a SIEM as separate security silos triage one attack in several consoles; XDR links those signals into one incident.
Native, open and hybrid XDR
XDR products are usually described as native, open or hybrid, depending on where their data comes from:
- Native XDR is built on one vendor’s own agents and sensors. All five tested platforms start from this model.
- Open XDR ingests data from other vendors’ security tools. Stellar Cyber is built on this model.
- Hybrid XDR is a native platform that also ingests third-party data. All five tested platforms document such connectors, for example Okta in Bitdefender and Proofpoint in CrowdStrike.
XDR benchmark methodology
A yes/no criterion counts as met when vendor documentation describes the feature and names the license, module and settings it needs. Screenshots from our lab confirm it where the trial allowed. Graded sub-metrics count items from a fixed checklist applied to every vendor. We assign no weights and no total score.
Limitations:
- Memory is one snapshot per vendor, taken under that vendor’s own policy and workload.
- Installer time excludes console registration and policy download.
- Trend Micro was not tested on Linux because the trial tenant had no Linux license.
- We checked features behind separate licenses, such as Sovereign Private Cloud, in documentation only.
FAQs
An XDR (extended detection and response) solution collects security data from endpoints, email, identity systems, network sensors and cloud workloads, correlates it into incidents, and runs response actions from one console. It extends endpoint detection and response (EDR) beyond the host, so security teams get threat detection and response in one place.
Linking events across sources helps expose multi-stage attacks, such as those by advanced persistent threat groups.
Collect: agents and connectors send data from multiple security layers (endpoint, email, identity, network and cloud) to one platform. All five tested platforms take in endpoint, email and identity data.
Correlate: analytics group related security events into incidents. One Trend Micro Workbench insight grouped 69 alerts and tracked the attack stages they covered.
Respond: playbooks isolate hosts, quarantine files or block accounts. Acronis documents blocking an Entra ID account, and its playbooks closed new incidents as “Auto mitigated” once enabled.
Correlation is meant to cut false positives and the number of alerts security analysts review, by checking one alert against signals from other sources. Our test did not measure false-positive rates.
All five tested vendors document endpoint protection that keeps running offline with the required modules and settings; we did not test disconnected endpoints. Among the five, only Trend Micro documents full XDR analytics with no internet connection, through Sovereign Private Cloud.
All five tested vendors document a recovery path, but only Acronis, Bitdefender and Sophos restore automatically. In our live tests, Acronis restored all 17 test files in a RanSim run with its EDR pack enabled; runs with the pack off and a different encryption script restored none. Bitdefender quarantined the test script before it could encrypt anything; with a scan exclusion, it restored none of the encrypted files.
Cite this research
Pick the format that matches where you're publishing. Pasting the link version into your CMS preserves the backlink.
@misc{dogan2026,
author = {Dogan, Sedat and Arslan, Ezgi},
title = {{Top 11 XDR Solutions Comparison and Features}},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
howpublished = {\url{https://aimultiple.com/xdr-solutions}},
note = {AIMultiple. Retrieved October 30, 2026}
}Results and timestamps of 75 data points. Download the summary data shown in this article's charts and tables as a ZIP file containing 15 CSV files.
Want the granular data behind it? Join Premium
Changelog
2 updatesAdded an XDR benchmark summary section with per-vendor findings for Acronis, Sophos, CrowdStrike, Bitdefender and Trend Micro.
Added a hands-on benchmark section covering Acronis, CrowdStrike, Sophos, Bitdefender and Trend Micro, with full vendor reviews.
Reference Links
- Has 20 years of experience as a white-hat hacker and development guru, with extensive expertise in programming languages and server architectures.
- Is a board advisor at a VC investing in early-stage technology firms and at Ödeal, a regional digital payment platform serving 125,000 merchants.
- Has led the technology infrastructure and cybersecurity of seven national elections, and has been recognized in the cybersecurity Hall of Fame by global technology leaders including Twitter.
Be the first to comment
Your email address will not be published. All fields are required. Comments are left in their original language.